I made view "A".
Peplum tops are really popular right now, so thought I'd jump on the bandwagon.
I made my usual size 14, with a few alterations. I added 1" to the bodice length and also 1-1/2" to the skirt length. I also added a little to the center from the waist down-more in the back than the front. Now mine fits me like the model's on the pattern envelope.
I like the pleats at the neckline and extended shoulder/sleeves. I'm a little narrow through the shoulders and upper chest, and often have problems with necklines being too wide, but this fits perfectly.
This is a quick and easy top to make. The view I made has only 3 pieces: a bodice front & back, plus the peplum. You make a casing and insert elastic for the waist.
The fabric I used is a soft cotton - I love the print. I can see this made up a variety of fabrics - even a stable knit would work. I've already worn it and it's very comfortable. I like my new summer top and be using this pattern again. I plan to make the V-neck version too.